Allow 48 hours to process online orders.
Curbside pickup can be made during regular business hours as posted on our ‘Contact Page’.
$12.95
Pure milk chocolate on the outside, smooth creamy peanut butter on the inside. These gourmet peanut butter cups are the upgrade to the childhood memories of this popular flavor combination you’ve been waiting for.
In stock
Milk Chocolate Raisins$6.95
Milk Chocolate Peanuts$6.95
Dark Chocolate NonPariels$14.95
Milk Chocolate NonPariels$14.95
Malted Milk Balls$5.95
Caramels – Milk Chocolate with Sea Salt$12.95
Almonds$7.50
Classic Sampler$28.95 – $56.95
Orange Peel$12.95
English Toffee & Truffles$30.95
English Toffee$26.95 – $52.95
Caramel Nut Paws$17.95 – $54.95
Petite Pecan Patties$18.95 – $37.95
Truffle Assortment$30.95
Chicago The Windy City Gift Tier$69.95
Chicago Truffles$30.95
Chicago Toffee$16.95
Salted Caramels$17.95
Holiday Gift Tier$42.95
Ultimate Holiday Gift Tier$99.95
Ultimate Holiday Sampler$32.95 – $64.95
Caramel Apples$5.50 – $8.95
Dipped Strawberries$11.95 – $19.95
Madagascar Vanilla Bean$10.95
Toffee Espresso Fudge$10.95
Peppermint ‘Ice Ice Baby’$10.95
Double Dutch Chocolate Chocolate$10.95
Double Butter Toffee$10.95